I can understand where fellow student's comments are worthwhile when doing a school project or another type of evaluated/graded project. It is like having a bevy of editors at your fingertips.
I am not as comfortable leaving random comments about random blogs. It seems a little creepy to be reading other's opinions, feelings, etc. Of course, they wouldn't put it on line if they didn't want it read by strangers, I guess.
Blog commenting has to be only positive and constructive...it could be hurtful in the wrong hands (I'm thinking 6th grade girls!)
I agree with you about leaving comments on random blogs, but as a fellow participant of 23 Things I feel some kind of camaraderie even though we have never met. I enjoy reading other 23 Thing blogs, especially those that have comments. They often help me think about how to improve my own blog.
ReplyDeleteI agree. Commenting should be positive and constructive. I think it is important to model, model, model what we expect from students. We'll have to teach them to be helpful, not hurtful. I also think it's a good idea to set things up so that the teacher has to "approve" all student comments before they are posted "live". That would give us a chance to work with students on how to phrase their comments before any problems arise.
ReplyDeleteI can tell you that leaving comments on strangers' blogs is not creepy at all...but then, I am the type to start up a conversation in a grocery store line!
ReplyDelete